President Donald Trump made false and deceptive statements in an try and distinction his stance on regulation enforcement with that of Joe Biden, his Democratic opponent within the presidential race:
- The president claimed in an Oct. 10 marketing campaign rally on the White House — his first marketing campaign occasion since he contracted COVID-19 — that within the presidential debate, Biden “couldn’t even use the words law enforcement.” He did.
- Trump additionally claimed that Biden mentioned, “When you call 911, a therapist should answer the call.” He didn’t. Biden mentioned psychological health consultants ought to accompany police on some calls, a coverage Trump additionally supported in a June government order.
Trump made his claims from a White House balcony, addressing a crowd of supporters on the South Lawn, within the occasion organized by the conservative group Blexit, which requires Black Americans to exit the Democratic Party. And he repeated a number of the claims in an Oct. 12 marketing campaign rally in Florida.
The president’s reelection marketing campaign has cultivated a “law and order” theme, falsely portraying Biden as a supporter of defunding the police. Biden has mentioned repeatedly that he doesn’t help defunding the police, as he wrote in an op-ed revealed in USA Today on June 10. While he has mentioned he would help shifting some funding from regulation enforcement to social service businesses, Biden additionally has talked about rising funding for departments that comply with “implement meaningful reforms.”
The Biden marketing campaign additionally instructed us in an announcement in June that Biden helps extra money for initiatives that may strengthen the connection between the police and the neighborhood and for body-worn cameras.
Biden’s Debate Comments
Trump referred to what Biden mentioned, or didn’t say, on the Sept. 29 presidential debate.
Trump, Oct. 10: The different day within the debate Biden couldn’t even use the phrases regulation enforcement. I mentioned, “Say law enforcement. Say law enforcement,” and he was bailed out by the anchor. Then I mentioned, very merely I mentioned, “Name one law enforcement group that’s supporting you,” he couldn’t do it, however he was bailed out by the anchor. Second time bailed. He acquired bailed out by that anchor so much. Taking their funds away, their firearms, their basic authorities, taking all the pieces away, together with your freedom. Joe Biden even mentioned, “When you call 911, a therapist should answer the call.” That doesn’t work. That doesn’t work.
In an Oct. 12 rally in Florida, Trump repeated a couple of of these claims, saying: “At our debate, Biden could not name a single law enforcement organization that supports him, not one.” And: “Then I said, say the words ‘law enforcement,’ just say it. Couldn’t do it, he couldn’t say it.”
At one level within the debate, Trump mentioned to Biden: “You can’t even say the word ‘law enforcement’ because if you say those words, you’re going to lose all of your radical left supporters. And why aren’t you saying those words, Joe? Why don’t you say the words ‘law enforcement’?”
After Trump completed his feedback, moderator Chris Wallace turned to his subsequent query, saying, “All right. I want to return to the question of race.” So Biden didn’t reply to Trump’s feedback then, however Biden mentioned “law enforcement” in his reply to Wallace’s query about race, happening to say “the vast majority of police officers are good, decent, honorable men and women.”
Here’s what was mentioned instantly after Trump completed asking Biden to “say the words law enforcement”:
Wallace, Sept. 29 debate: All proper. I wish to return to the query of race. Vice President Biden, after the grand jury within the Breonna Taylor case determined to not cost any of the police with murder, you mentioned it raises the query, quote “whether justice could be equally applied in America.” Do you imagine that there’s a separate however unequal system of justice for Blacks on this nation?
Biden: Yes, there may be. There’s systemic injustice on this nation. In schooling, in work and in regulation enforcement and the way in which through which it’s enforced. But look, the overwhelming majority of law enforcement officials are good, first rate, honorable women and men. They threat their lives each day to maintain us. But there are some dangerous apples. And after they happen, after they discover them, they must be sorted out. They must be held accountable. They must be held accountable.
And what I’m going to do as president of the United States is name collectively a complete group of individuals on the White House, all the pieces from the civil rights teams to the law enforcement officials, the police chiefs, and we’re going to work this out.
We’re going to work this out so we modify the way in which through which we’ve extra transparency in when these items occur. These cops aren’t completely happy to see what occurred to George Floyd. These cops aren’t completely happy to see what occurred to Breonna Taylor. Most don’t prefer it. But we’ve to have a system the place individuals are held accountable.
And, by the way in which, violence in response is rarely applicable. Never applicable. Peaceful protest is, violence is rarely applicable.
Later within the debate, Biden once more used the phrases “law enforcement” when Wallace requested him about language in the Biden-Sanders Unity Task Force Recommendations, a doc containing coverage suggestions from Biden and Sen. Bernie Sanders, launched in early July.
Wallace: I do wish to speak about this situation of regulation and order although, and within the joint advice that got here from the Biden-Bernie Sanders job pressure, you talked about quote, “reimagining policing.” First of all, what does reimagining policing imply and do you help … If I’d end the query. What does reimagining policing imply and do you help the Black Lives Matter name for neighborhood management of policing?
Biden: Look, what I help is the police having the chance to cope with the issues they face. I’m completely against defunding the police workplaces. As a matter of reality, native police. The just one defunding, and his finances requires a $400 million reduce in native regulation enforcement help. They want extra help.
They want, after they present up for a 911 name, to have somebody with them as a psychologist or psychiatrist to maintain them from having to make use of pressure and be capable of discuss folks down. We must have neighborhood policing like we had earlier than, the place the officers get to know the folks within the communities.
Trump claimed in his Oct. 10 occasion that “Biden even mentioned, ‘When you call 911, a therapist should answer the call.’” That appears to be a reference to Biden’s comment that the police ought to “have someone with them as a psychologist or psychiatrist to keep them from having to use force and be able to talk people down.” While Trump added, “That doesn’t work,” the president, actually, has proposed an identical coverage.
On June 16, Trump signed an government order on policing that referred to as for “co-responder programs, which involve social workers or other mental health professionals working alongside law enforcement officers so that they arrive and address situations together.”
Executive Order on Safe Policing for Safe Communities, June 16: The Attorney General shall, in session with the Secretary of Health and Human Services as applicable, determine and develop alternatives to coach regulation enforcement officers with respect to encounters with people affected by impaired psychological health, homelessness, and dependancy; to extend the capability of social employees working instantly with regulation enforcement businesses; and to supply steerage relating to the event and implementation of co-responder packages, which contain social employees or different psychological health professionals working alongside regulation enforcement officers in order that they arrive and deal with conditions collectively.
The Biden-Sanders coverage doc accommodates comparable language, calling for: “Federal funding to create a civilian corps of unarmed first responders such as social workers, EMTs, and trained mental health professionals, who can handle nonviolent emergencies including order maintenance violations, mental health emergencies, and low-level conflicts outside the criminal justice system, freeing police officers to concentrate on the most serious crimes. Fund initiatives to partner mental health professionals, substance use disorder experts, social workers, and disability advocates with police departments to respond to calls with police officers to better de-escalate interactions with citizens and when appropriate, to divert individuals to the social services they need.”
We requested the Trump marketing campaign what the distinction was between Biden’s name for psychological health professionals to reply with police to calls and Trump’s government order supporting “co-responder programs” with “social workers or other mental health professionals.” We haven’t obtained a response.
As for Biden’s declare within the debate that Trump’s finances “calls for a $400 million cut in local law enforcement assistance,” Trump’s 2021 finances did name for a discount in funding, in contrast with what Congress enacted in 2020, for a bunch of federal Justice Department packages that pertain to state and native regulation enforcement. Our fact-checking colleagues at PolitiFact discovered the online discount was $515 million, although $100 million of that issues safety on the nationwide occasion conventions (which wouldn’t be wanted in a 2021 finances).
The largest proposed reductions had been to the Community Oriented Policing Services program (which the Trump finances proposed reorganizing), the Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grants (which gives prison justice grants to state and native governments) and the State Criminal Alien Assistance Program (which pays state and native entities for wage prices related to incarcerating immigrants who’re within the nation illegally and dedicated sure crimes).
But one knowledgeable instructed PolitiFact that a number of the packages fund what’s higher described as public security targets slightly than direct help to regulation enforcement.
Law Enforcement Endorsements
Trump additionally claimed that on the debate, he requested Biden to “name one law enforcement group that’s supporting you” and Biden “couldn’t do it.”
It’s true that Biden didn’t title anybody on the debate when Trump requested him to take action. But, as we wrote in our story on the controversy, Biden is backed by some present and former regulation enforcement officers. The marketing campaign launched a listing of greater than 190 officers who say they help Biden, together with present and former law enforcement officials, sheriffs, attorneys basic and district attorneys.
Trump has been endorsed by the National Association of Police Organizations and the Fraternal Order of Police, in addition to state and native police organizations, resembling the union for New York City officers.
Editor’s Note: Please contemplate a donation to FactCheck.org. We don’t settle for promoting. We depend on grants and particular person donations from folks such as you. Credit card donations could also be made by means of our “Donate” web page. If you favor to offer by test, ship to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, 202 S. 36th St., Philadelphia, PA 19104.
This reality test is accessible at IFCN’s 2020 US Elections FactChat #Chatbot on WhatsApp. Click right here for extra.